#15. tUnE-yArDs – w h o k i l l
2011 was big on introspection, short on overtly political music. Step up Merril Garbus, who starts w h o k i l l with 'My country 'tis of thee / sweet land of liberty / how come I cannot see my future within your arms?' The America of w h o k i l l is a nightmarish collage of consumerism, racial tension, simmering violence and privilege - or lack thereof.
Musically it builds on the ultra lo-fi loops 'n racket of debut album Bird Brain, a gleeful riot of sounds both beautiful (the gorgeous, swooping backing harmonies of 'Powa') and dischordant (basically every instrument throughout 'Riotriot'). But what really makes w h o k i l l stand out is our narrator. Garbus' voice is a magnificent weapon that she weilds with extreme prejudice, blessed with Carey's range but the dynamism of Isaac Brock. And with this incredibly expressive weapon she relays, for example, her body anxiety; 'I gotta be right, if my body's tight, right?' delivered like a Pepsi ad girl in 'Esso', or 'Powa''s candid homage to a lover who makes her forget about her body altogether. By being everything but also defiantly herself, Garbus makes for a very 21st century angry-young-woman.
#14. Panda Bear - Tomboy
Of all the beloved albums followed up in 2011, Panda Bear's Person Pitch surely provided the most thankless task. It's a handful of note-perfect experiments wrapped around two twelve minute, shape-shifting, indie-prog monsters. It's also so universally beloved that the reason you may not have heard of it is that everyone who hears it becomes an insanely possessive Mama Bear. By the time the much-delayed Tomboy arrived on the scene, following a steady drip feed of rough demos, singles and concept art, it was bundled with a hype you might call 'Christopher Nolan-esque'. As a result, the comparatively relaxed and simple set of songs it contained were given what constitutes a hard time in the blogging community; mildly positive reviews, limited hysteria and a bit of a brush-off.
All of which is unfair; though it might lack Person Pitch's ambition and invention, Tomboy is still a consistent and extremely likeable album that deserves to be lauded as a separate entity. Though still heavily processed, Noah Lennox's vocals are brought right to the top of the mix, and the gorgeous harmonies (which, if his Animal Collective day job is anything to go by, come to him as naturally as digestion) are now wrapped around what are basically 3 or 4 minute pop songs, with choruses and everything. The mood shifts subtly but never jars; 'Last Night at the Jetty' is blissful and carefree, while 'Scheherazade' is quite unsettling, but the difference is sound is little more than a shift from major to minor, mid-tempo to slow, guitar to piano, gentle riff to sparse chords. We're left with the overall impression that this isn't so much a follow-up to Person Pitch as the album Lennox wanted to make just now.
#13. Bon Iver – Bon Iver
Nobody expected For Emma, Forever Ago to do any business at all, least of all Justin Vernon. Brilliant though it may be, it sounds very much like something he had to get done just to keep his head together, a hugely cathartic document of utter desolation. Fortunately for Justin, loads of people are sometimes sad and love pretty music, so what was intended as a deeply personal eulogy for his old band (DeYarmond Edison, half of which put out an excellent LP last year as Megafaun) became a word-of-mouth megahit of Paranormal Activity proportions, leaving the follow up, if there was even going to be one, with a weight of expectation akin to the second coming of Christ.
Fortunately for him/us, Vernon lives and breathes this shit. Where For Emma felt trapped, Bon Iver is a journey, wide-eyed and elated, through an unknown country. The song titles may be locations but they're unfamiliar, and god knows the lyrics aren't giving anything away either. Though the music is, at his heart, Americana-infused folk-rock, washes of synths, keyboard tones and autotuned vocals (which Vernon has pretty much 'won' at this point) infuse it with a further degree of unfamiliarity, leaving us with a strange beast; an alien, ambiguous record which somehow feels incredibly personal. When it originally leaked back in March I guiltily acquired it and proceeded to tell pretty much no-one. It was mine, and christ knows I wasn't going to let anyone else in until I was done with it.
#12. St Vincent - Strange Mercy
Someone must have made an unkind comment about the flutes. We got a few glimpses of Annie Clark: Shred Monster throughout 2009's masterful-but-kinda-twee Actor, but nothing save for a few choice covers at charity events could have prepared us for this in-the-red snarl, the frenzied collapse and pull together of 'Northern Lights', the corrosive, jagged stabs that punctuate 'Chloe in the Afternoon''s impressionist s&m fantasy. But then we really should have seen this coming; she may look and sound every bit like a china doll (something which the promo shoots for Strange Mercy pretty much all picked up on), but her first album opened with 'Now, Now''s barrage of thinly veiled, creepily sing songy threats: 'I'm not the carpet you walk on.. I'll make you sorry'.
Sex and violence hang over Strange Mercy like a dark cloud, and not always seperately; gently cooed statements and pleas like 'I've had good times / with some bad guys / I've told whole lies / with a half smile' and 'best finest surgeon / come cut me open' drip with barely concealed lust and palpable danger, but Clark's playfully ambiguous narrator darts wantonly from character to character, and at times it's difficult to tell whether she's inflicting or receiving. It's this willingness for - nay, delight in - mischief that makes for such a compelling listen. Best of all is the gloriously bonkers 'Surgeon', with its gloriously addictive and disquieting electonic riff, completely ridiculous keyboard solo and my favourite moment in any song last year: it's an 'Eh!', and you'll know it when you hear it.
#11. Destroyer - Kaputt
Over the last fifteen years or so, Destroyer mastermind Dan Bejar has quietly cemented his reputation as one of the most consistent songwriters around in a number of different forms, whether as the apocalyptic Bowie (Streethawk: A Seduction) or as an ambient-drone mastermind ('Bay of Pigs', a new, slightly tweaked version of which closes Kaputt). For his latest outing, he's only used instrumentation that hasn't really been cool since 1983, and was kind of touch-and-go even then. But unlike, say, 'Beth/Rest' - which, masterful though it may be, jars ferociously on first listen - there's nothing heavy-handed about these horns and synths. This is easy listening in the truest sense, and that's absolutely a compliment.
It's hardly just a random aesthetic decision anyway; it's the ideal set dressing for the stage where our narrator, an aging playboy reflecting on his golden years, delivers his 'Mr November', 'Death of A Ladies Man' shtick with an easy charm, humour and the slightest hint of melancholy. The sublime title track's opening lines nail it: 'Wasting your days, chasing some girls / alright chasing cocaine, through the backrooms of the world all night'. Witty, evocative and delivered with exactly the right amount of literary flair. But it goes deeper than that too, and a little prodding reveals subtle in-jokes, cross-references, sly nods to other bands and songs; 'Suicide Demo for Kara Walker', a fascinating, highly conceptual collaboration with artist and racial history commentator Kara Walker is so-called because it reminded Bejar of a Suicide track. So, we have an album that's not only really nice to listen to, but also one that's rich in depth which improves with every listen. Is there seriously anything else you could want?